I read the book ‘She needs’ by Naomi Dawson a number of weeks ago and was planning to write a review to share with you all but as it turns out John Stephens, Director of FIEC has done a very good review himself and thought I would share that instead:
A couple of weeks ago I read Nay Dawson’s new book ‘She Needs.’ It is a heartfelt challenge to church leaders to ensure that women flourish in church and can use their God-given gifts to help edify the body of Christ.
Paradoxically it is both an easy read and a difficult read. It is an easy read because it is relatively short (just 100 pages), clear concise and not complicated. It is a difficult read (at least for me) because it relates how women have been treated in church, including testimony and stories.
Although Nay would be egalitarian in her convictions it is not an anti-complementarian book. She is careful to respect the views of complementarian churches and leaders. In that sense, the book is not threatening or polemical.
However, it does reveal the patronising way that some complementarians have treated women in church, and their refusal to recognise and utilise their gifts.
When I became a Christian in 1988 the egalitarian-complementarian issue was hotting up, exacerbated by the debates about women’s ordination within the Church of England and the emergence of a more robust theological complementarianism associated with the CBMW. The church was coming to terms with both social change and internal pressure to overturn established norms.
Over the years I have changed my views on the outworking of complementarianism and shifted from an ontological to a more functional/role-based understanding of the differences between men and women. The reason that I found the book uncomfortable was that some of the attitudes displayed and theological convictions related that made me wince were things I had thought in the past, perhaps even taught or done.
Nay’s approach is to draw on secular research, for example from the business world, to highlight the barriers that prevent women from reaching their full potential and then show how this is replicated in the church context. This research highlights the way that women feel about themselves in our culture and the need for greater encouragement and support to put themselves forward and exercise their gifts.
In many ways, this is a fundamentally complementarian perspective. It recognises that men and women cannot be treated identically. This will not enable both to flourish. They need to be treated in ways that are sensitive to their psychological makeup and the wider cultural context. Characteristically many men overrate their gifting and push themselves forward, whereas women tend to underrate their gifts and be reticent. Wise pastoral leadership will take this into account.
I think this is a book that every church leader ought to read, especially those who are complementarian. Leadership teams could usefully read it to conduct an audit of their churches and whether they are making some of the mistakes identified that prevent women from using their gifts, which can only be a loss to the church as a whole.
The book will help make leaders think more carefully about the questions that they ought to be asking the women in their churches. We ought to listen attentively and curiously to their experiences and carefully consider whether the way we speak and teach is (perhaps inadvertently) preventing them from serving in ways that the Bible clearly encourages.
It ought also not to be presumed that egalitarian churches are more effective at enabling women to use their gifts to serve the body. They may be de facto male-led and dominated despite their theological convictions. I am aware of complementarian initiatives to invest in women’s ministry to very high levels of theological competence (eg TGC and to a lesser extent within FIEC) and don’t know if that would be the case within more egalitarian contexts.
I was reading Acts 2 yesterday, and one of the characteristics of the new covenant in the last days is that the Holy Spirit is poured out on men and women alike so that both can prophesy, something that is realised in the church in 1 Corinthians 12-14 for example. In my view, Biblical complementarianism ought not operate out of a negative fear that makes restriction the dominant tone, but from a positive enthusiasm for the gifts given to women that makes the utilisation of their Spirit-given gifts a blessing to the body.
I am left with a couple of questions after reading the book:
First, I wonder whether it accurately reflects contemporary church life, especially in complementarian churches. I hope some of the worst examples reflect the culture of 20-30 years ago when our thinking was much less careful and nuanced, and more reactive/defensive against the rise of feminism within the church. In my experience, the understanding and application of complementarianism are much more careful today. I do, however, fear the renewed rise of a harder-edged patriarchal approach that is being shaped in the US as a result of the evangelical response to the culture wars.
Second, it is interesting that many of the studies Nay quotes are from secular contexts. This suggests that the insights they bring about the difference between men and women are not a product of the evangelical church sub-subculture alone. This at least raises the question of whether there are in some way more deep-rooted differences between men and women that are not purely cultural in origin, because the research indicates that they are much more widespread. That somewhat ironically tends to support the complementarian claim that men and women are not simply interchangeable, but rather equal but different. Perhaps we need to celebrate and understand that difference, working with it rather than against it, rather than pretending it is not there, or is a mere cultural construct.
I would encourage all leaders to read this book – not because they will necessarily agree with it but because it is essential that they at least consider the issues that it raises within their churches and carefully reflect on whether there are significant changes that they ought to make in their speaking, teaching and practice towards their sisters in Christ.
I would also add, that this isn’t just for church leaders, this is for us all and we should take it very seriously.
John Millist